The IB13 case study blog
This blog is used by IB13a in Geography DP. The students will blog mainly about China in all areas of the syllabus where China or other areas can be used as a case study.
China
onsdag 18 mars 2015
onsdag 4 mars 2015
Palm oil poster from Annie, Sol and Maria
It's not about China, but nevertheless deserves some attention.
fredag 21 november 2014
“HDI: Is a composite statistic of life expectancy, education and income indices used to rank countries into four tiers of human development.” - WIKIPEDIA
Pros:
“measures chosen are easy and cheap to collect
• measures chosen are fairly reliable
• indicates GDP has been used to increase social
welfare
• GDP rank minus HDI rank as a useful measure
or health and education
• use of education and health is a sign of
successful government policies
• shift of PPF or AS curve outwards as a sign of
increased potential without increases in costs,
so HDI rank is a sign of welfare in the future” - Thestudentroom
Cons: The cons of HDI
- Wide divergence within countries. For example, countries like China and Kenya have widely different HDI scores depending on the region in question. (e.g. north China poorer than south east)
- HDI reflect long-term changes (e.g. life expectancy) and may not respond to recent short-term changes.
- Higher National wealth GDI may not necessarily increase economic welfare, it depends how it is spent.
- Also higher GDI per capita may hide widespread inequality within a country. Some countries with higher real GDI per capita have high levels of inequality (e.g. Russia, Saudi Arabia)
- However, HDI can highlight countries with similar GDI per capita but different levels of economic development.
- Economic welfare depends on several other factors, such as – threat of war, levels of pollution, access to clean drinking water e.t.c.
GCI: Is “the unseen, yet unreachable barrier that keeps minorities and women from rising to the upper rungs of the corporate ladder, regardless of their qualifications or achievements.” - WIKIPEDIA
David Cotter and colleagues defined four distinctive characteristics that must be met to conclude that a “glass ceiling” exist:
- "A gender or racial difference that is not explained by other job-relevant characteristics of the employee."
- "A gender or racial difference that is greater at higher levels of an outcome than at lower levels of an outcome."
- "A gender or racial inequality in the chances of advancement into higher levels, not merely the proportions of each gender or race currently at those higher levels."
- "A gender or racial inequality that increases over the course of a career."
The GC’s existence at workplaces can be difficult to prove since it is difficult to find proof for that the workplace achieves the characteristics. To be more specific, a “glass ceiling” might exist, but it can be very difficult to prove that the workplace is hindering women's movement without the cause being something else (bar being due to gender).
måndag 10 november 2014
Blog post nutrition: Hadir, Hilma, Rebecca, Callum
Group 2: Hadir, Hilma, Callum , Rebecca
- How can you measure nutrition? How good/bad of an indicator is it?
There are many different nutrition measurements index and some of them are:
- WHO (World Health Organization): an index where they measure infant and young child feeding data by country.
According WHO for children under 5 years old in China, the prevalence of underweight ranged from 3% in Beijing to 39% in the province of Hainan while that of stunting ranged from 7% in Beijing to 56% in Guizhou. Children in the provinces of Fujian, Jiangxi, Hunan, Guangxi, Hainan, Sichuan, Guizhou, Yunnan, Qinghai and Xinjiang were found to be highly affected by stunting (>40%) and those in Guangxi and Hainan also showed a prevalence of underweight >30%. (http://www.fao.org/ag/agn/nutrition/chn_en.stm)
- U5MR (is the under-five mortality rate): an important indicator of the socio-economic development and health and nutritional status of a society was found to be 47‰ in 1996 in China. (http://www.fao.org/ag/agn/nutrition/chn_en.stm)
- BMI (Body Mass Index): The BMI values of people in China were similar for both males and females (22.0 kg/m2). About 10% of the adult population had a BMI below 18.5 kg/m2 while a significant proportion were overweight or obese (15%). (http://www.fao.org/ag/agn/nutrition/chn_en.stm)
- The national average intake of energy slightly decreased from 2485 to 2328 kcal/caput/day between 1982 and 1992 and this is probably due to the more sedentary lifestyle of the population in China. (http://www.fao.org/ag/agn/nutrition/chn_en.stm)
- United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) Index of Undernutrition: is a nutritional index that is used to calculate by considering three parameters: per capita availability of food, inequality of energy intake, and age/sex-specific nutritional requirements. (http://www.uniteforsight.org/nutrition/module9)
- Global Hunger Index (GHI) : is used to measure malnutrition across countries and is also used to increase international attention to the problem of global malnutrition. (http://www.uniteforsight.org/nutrition/module9)
- Action Aid’s HungerFREE Scorecard: The NGO Action Aid has developed an index that measures nutrition outcomes as well as a country’s political commitment to combating undernutrition. (http://www.uniteforsight.org/nutrition/module9)
- GNI/GDP. Define and explain. Pros and cons? What is PPP? Why is that useful? As a marginalization index.
FTC: calculate nutrient values for the dietary data of 2000 and previous years
GDP/GNP/GNI per capita: The amount of money made by a country divided by its population. See above for specific explanations.
GDP: $10.355 trillion (nominal; 2014 est.
Malnutrition rate: The percentage of children underweight or under height for their age.
Calorie Intake: The average number of calories consumed by different age groups.
(define nourishment indicators - look for maps - conclusions and anomalies body mass index - starvation - undernourishment - vitamin deficiency diseases - GNI/GDP - pros and cons Purchase and Parole Pality - values of dollars in a country - what are you able to get from your money)
Calorie intake (China 2005): 2970 kcal/person/day
% of Undernourished people (China 2005): 12%
The map above shows the global BMI. It conveys different numbers that describe if the population of the countries are healthy, overweight or undernourished.
Values less than 18.5 indicate that the population are undernourished and on the map its the countries that is white coloured (<22.5) e.g. some of the African countries and India. The healthy values range between 18.5-24.9, which indicate that the country have a healthy population. In the map its the values 22.50 - 26.00, countries with light green colour e.g. China, France, Russia. Values ranging from 25 up to 29.9 represent a country with an overweight population. These are the countries with dark green colour on the map (>26.2) e.g. USA, Sweden, Australia, South Africa.
China is marked with a light green colour with the value 22.5-25 (kg/m2) on the map. Its correct because the BMI value of people in China (both female and males) is approximately (22.0 kg/m2).
The China Health and Nutrition Survey (CHNS) is an ongoing collaborative project between other institutes and universities, was designed to examine the effects of the health, nutrition and family planning policies and the programs implemented by national/local governments and to check how the social and economic transformation of Chinese society is affecting the health and nutritional status of its population.
- How can you measure nutrition? How good/bad of an indicator is it?
One can measure nutrition through the use of the BMI, also Body Mass Index. It describes the correlation between weight and height, where it should present a linear relationship. The weight of a person is divided by the height raised to the power of two. The BMI can thus portray both obesity and undernourishment. An individual with a BMI of less than 18.5 is undernourished. Values between 18,5-24,9 presents a normal and healthy value. Values ranging from 25 up to 29,9 represents an overweight person. BMI’s above 30 show individuals suffering from obesity. In China, the BMI of both women and men are of similar values with a general value of 22kg/m2. The Chinese population is thereby beholding a general value of a normal and healthy population. Yet, as always with single component indexes, we face the struggle of not being able to measure the cleavages within societies. 10% of the Chinese population are undernourished whilst 15% of it is overweight. The socio-economic differences between the Chinese provinces are essential faults in giving us an unfair perspective of the levels of nutrition.
World Health Organization, also WHO, has measured the infant and young child feeding data by country. Through this survey we are given the ability to see how large proportion of the children that have accessibility to appropriate amounts of nutrition. However, it does not give us a reliable account of the proportion of undernourished children. Not all data is collected in the suburbs i.e. in the areas where malnutrition occur to largest extent. This causes a lack in the reported levels.
Nutrition can also be measured through the national average intake of energy. The recommended level of nutrition varies from 2000-2500. By calculating the average calorie intake we are given a general perspective of a country’s level of nutrition. United States, most well known for being an unhealthy nation, is topping the list with a general of 3770 calories/capita a day. Eritrea is at the bottom of the list with a general of 1590 calories/capita a day.
Finally, another index that is commonly used when measuring nutrition is the GHI, the Global Hunger Index. It is giving us a more detailed perspective compared to the other indexes. That is because it is a multi-component index. It includes availability of food, child malnourishment and child mortality. These are calculated through proportion of the population that are food/energy deficient, the amount of children under five that are undernourished and children under five mortality rate. The GHI is very specific yet it gives us a broad image of the matter. Still, it does not include food security nor the undernourished adults. But the use of various statistics and data is important in gaining a fair perspective of malnourishment.
All indexes are essential in the way that they convey and put numbers on the global suffering. They make a more concrete notion of what is going on in the world and shows us how large percentage of the world’s population that live under constant hunger. Thus, it contributes with awareness and advocates attention to the issue.
- GNI/GDP. Define and explain. Pros and cons? What is PPP? Why is that useful? As a marginalization index.
GDP, also Gross Domestic Product, presents the total value of all goods and services produced domestically by a nation during a year. In 2013 China ranked 2nd highest as a world economy through measurement of GDP, according to the World Bank. When the GDP was divided per capita, they rank significantly lower. By the nominal GDP/capita China is placed as the 89th country globally. Evidentially, GDP is a partial vague index which does not show the socio-economic cleavages of a country. Yet, GDP does give us a general image of what the economy of a specific country looks like.
GNI, also Gross National Income, presents the total value of goods and services produced within a country together with the balance of income and payments from or to other countries. The most clear difference between GDP and GNI is that GDP base their data on location whilst GNI base it on ownership. GNI does thereby include the foreign trade, export and import. It is as a result becoming more increasingly preferred over GDP. China’s GNI/capita is 6,560 USD. Compared to Sweden this is fairly low, when the Swedish value is 59,240 USD. But if comparing it to Tanzania with only 630 GNI/capita, the Chinese value can be considered quite high.
PPP, Purchasing Power Parity, is the current international dollar. It compares levels of goods and services between different countries, expressing price in a shared currency . It does create a “common currency” and does essentially, when comparing, contribute with a shared starting point i.e. giving one the ability to compare countries. PPP is mostly used when measuring GDP in USD. The negative factors of PPP is its inability to measure short term changes. It only presents long-term exchange rates and miss out on the uncertainties.
However, an economy is not a single factor explaining development and success. Yet, it is a large one. One can easily miss out on the purpose of the economic indexes mentioned above. The values can be misleading if a country has got large cleavages, but they do contribute to a general information of a country’s economic fluctuation.
tisdag 21 oktober 2014
Sol, Annie, Maria and Claudia on group 1.
Summary of differences between single component index and composite index:
Single component indicators measure one certain aspect of a country or region. These measures often fall into one out of the three groups, it is either economic, social or demographic. Examples of a quantitative indicators would be GDP (Gross domestic product), life expectancy and doctors. A qualitative indicator would be welfare and security. Qualitative indicators try to describe rather than measure development, and is bad in ranking countries according to their development. Advantages of a single component index is that is can provide a great insight to a specific indicator, however it is not a reliable source to determine the economic, social and demographic attributes of a country. It simply measures one thing, which can be negative if one wants to look at different aspects. Composite indicators combine several different measures of development. For example, the HDI (Human development index) looks at GDP per capita, literacy and life expectancy to give a broader picture. Composite indicators are better than single component indicators in showing the different attributes of a country, as it shows several aspects. It can easily summarize a number of different indicators. However, the average scores a country receive may be dragged down by low scores in just one indicator. Countries can therefore claim that they are good in an index, even though a certain indicator of that index is extremely bad. For example, China’s HDI from 2013 was 0.719. However, that is not an accurate representation of the different indicators. China has a good life expectancy, which is 75 years, and literacy, which is 95%, yet the index is lowered by the GDP per capita which is only at $6.807. The main difference between the different indicators is the number of measures used. They both have problems with biases, informal economy and incorrect information. In addition, they do not showcase disparities within a country. In China for example, there is a difference in income in the east and the west, however that is not shown in the GDP per capita. There are still advantages to using indexes. For example, they are useful when a country wants to set goals for themselves, and in showing what areas need the most assistance.
Infant mortality rate:
Infant mortality rates are high where water supplies, sanitation, housing, healthcare and nutrition are insufficient i.e. the poorest LEDCs. But the infant mortality rate can differ within a country as well, for example like in China. Western China has a lower IMR than the East part. A cause of that can be that the Western part is richer than the Eastern and more cities are located in the West which means e.g. better healthcare. The IMR ranges from 3 per thousand live births in Shanghai in the west to more than 20 per thousand live births in Xinjiang and Tibet in the east.

Infant mortality rates are high where water supplies, sanitation, housing, healthcare and nutrition are insufficient i.e. the poorest LEDCs. But the infant mortality rate can differ within a country as well, for example like in China. Western China has a lower IMR than the East part. A cause of that can be that the Western part is richer than the Eastern and more cities are located in the West which means e.g. better healthcare. The IMR ranges from 3 per thousand live births in Shanghai in the west to more than 20 per thousand live births in Xinjiang and Tibet in the east.
Education:
Education is an important social indicator of development. There are several different ways to measure and compare education. To begin with, we can measure a country’s adult literacy rate. For example, in China the total literacy ratio of people age 15+ is 95%. This indicates a high social development, because to be literate, you have most likely gone to school. Educated people are very useful to help a country prosper, in both social and economical ways. The literacy ratio can also show disparities between genders. The adult male (15+) literacy ratio in China is 97%, whereas the adult female (15+) literacy ratio is only 93%. These numbers indicate a male preference when it comes to who receives education. This makes it likely that there is also a cultural male preference, which we know is the case in China.

Single component indicators measure one certain aspect of a country or region. These measures often fall into one out of the three groups, it is either economic, social or demographic. Examples of a quantitative indicators would be GDP (Gross domestic product), life expectancy and doctors. A qualitative indicator would be welfare and security. Qualitative indicators try to describe rather than measure development, and is bad in ranking countries according to their development. Advantages of a single component index is that is can provide a great insight to a specific indicator, however it is not a reliable source to determine the economic, social and demographic attributes of a country. It simply measures one thing, which can be negative if one wants to look at different aspects. Composite indicators combine several different measures of development. For example, the HDI (Human development index) looks at GDP per capita, literacy and life expectancy to give a broader picture. Composite indicators are better than single component indicators in showing the different attributes of a country, as it shows several aspects. It can easily summarize a number of different indicators. However, the average scores a country receive may be dragged down by low scores in just one indicator. Countries can therefore claim that they are good in an index, even though a certain indicator of that index is extremely bad. For example, China’s HDI from 2013 was 0.719. However, that is not an accurate representation of the different indicators. China has a good life expectancy, which is 75 years, and literacy, which is 95%, yet the index is lowered by the GDP per capita which is only at $6.807. The main difference between the different indicators is the number of measures used. They both have problems with biases, informal economy and incorrect information. In addition, they do not showcase disparities within a country. In China for example, there is a difference in income in the east and the west, however that is not shown in the GDP per capita. There are still advantages to using indexes. For example, they are useful when a country wants to set goals for themselves, and in showing what areas need the most assistance.
Infant mortality rate:
Infant mortality rate (IMR) refers to the number of children that die before their first birthday. It is expressed per thousand live births.
It is useful when comparing along time or countries, indicates quality of health care, water quality,food supply. The indicator is easy to understand and focuses on one of the most significant aspects of development. However there are some limitations such as the information may be incorrect, in LEDCs not all the births will be registered, the IMR rate is higher than what was disclosed and high infant mortality could be a result for social or political factors, for example the one child policy in China.
Survey data on infant mortality may omit births and deaths, include stillbirths with live births, have survivor selection bias and age truncation. It may also be that the mothers misreport the date their children were born, current age or age at death thus leading to an incorrect index. It is very common that the heapings happen at 12 months of age meaning age heaping may transfer deaths across the one year boundary and lead to underestimated infant mortality rate. Infant mortality rates are high where water supplies, sanitation, housing, healthcare and nutrition are insufficient i.e. the poorest LEDCs. But the infant mortality rate can differ within a country as well, for example like in China. Western China has a lower IMR than the East part. A cause of that can be that the Western part is richer than the Eastern and more cities are located in the West which means e.g. better healthcare. The IMR ranges from 3 per thousand live births in Shanghai in the west to more than 20 per thousand live births in Xinjiang and Tibet in the east.
It is useful when comparing along time or countries, indicates quality of health care, water quality,food supply. The indicator is easy to understand and focuses on one of the most significant aspects of development. However there are some limitations such as the information may be incorrect, in LEDCs not all the births will be registered, the IMR rate is higher than what was disclosed and high infant mortality could be a result for social or political factors, for example the one child policy in China.
Survey data on infant mortality may omit births and deaths, include stillbirths with live births, have survivor selection bias and age truncation. It may also be that the mothers misreport the date their children were born, current age or age at death thus leading to an incorrect index. It is very common that the heapings happen at 12 months of age meaning age heaping may transfer deaths across the one year boundary and lead to underestimated infant mortality rate. Infant mortality rates are high where water supplies, sanitation, housing, healthcare and nutrition are insufficient i.e. the poorest LEDCs. But the infant mortality rate can differ within a country as well, for example like in China. Western China has a lower IMR than the East part. A cause of that can be that the Western part is richer than the Eastern and more cities are located in the West which means e.g. better healthcare. The IMR ranges from 3 per thousand live births in Shanghai in the west to more than 20 per thousand live births in Xinjiang and Tibet in the east.
Education:
Education is an important social indicator of development. There are several different ways to measure and compare education. To begin with, we can measure a country’s adult literacy rate. For example, in China the total literacy ratio of people age 15+ is 95%. This indicates a high social development, because to be literate, you have most likely gone to school. Educated people are very useful to help a country prosper, in both social and economical ways. The literacy ratio can also show disparities between genders. The adult male (15+) literacy ratio in China is 97%, whereas the adult female (15+) literacy ratio is only 93%. These numbers indicate a male preference when it comes to who receives education. This makes it likely that there is also a cultural male preference, which we know is the case in China.
Another indicator which can be used to measure education is amount of mean years spent in school. This indicator also shows the disparities between the sexes. In China the amount of mean years in school per person for females age 25+ is 6.4 years. For males the same age group the number is 7.7 years. This indicates the previously seen trend of male preference in China. The mean years spent in school can also show how a country has developed over time. In China, the amount of years for women age 25+ has increased from 2.1 years in 1980, to the 6.4 years of 2010. The numbers for males the same age is from 4.3 years in 1980 to the 7.7 years of today. This not only shows that China has been through massive social development, it also shows that the gender disparities have grown lower through the years. From being a country where males had more than double the amount of years in school in 1980, to them only having about ⅙ more in 2010 is a clear improvement. Mean years of men 25+ in school , mean years of women 25+ in school .
These are different ways of measuring education, it can show development over time, as well as indicate sex preference. All figures are taken from gapminder, and if not otherwise stated, from the year 2010.
How can education be used to describe, compare and contrast marginalization?
Education can be used to describe marginalization; The poor families or the less socially accepted ones might not be able to or allowed to send their children to school, which means that they are marginalized.
When comparing and contrasting marginalization we can always use education. For example, social disadvantage (which includes school). That can lead to them not getting a job in the future. The marginalization of girls can show the disparities between gender and the discrimination that they receive regarding their education. For example, in China the difference in literacy rates between the genders can show a male preference and show that girls are left out. Marginalization of for example women and/or people of colour in education can result in lower status, self-esteem and job opportunities in the future. The marginalization of populations ultimately leads to lower living standards.
Education can be used to describe marginalization; The poor families or the less socially accepted ones might not be able to or allowed to send their children to school, which means that they are marginalized.
When comparing and contrasting marginalization we can always use education. For example, social disadvantage (which includes school). That can lead to them not getting a job in the future. The marginalization of girls can show the disparities between gender and the discrimination that they receive regarding their education. For example, in China the difference in literacy rates between the genders can show a male preference and show that girls are left out. Marginalization of for example women and/or people of colour in education can result in lower status, self-esteem and job opportunities in the future. The marginalization of populations ultimately leads to lower living standards.
söndag 21 september 2014
Skewed sex ratios in China
In China today there is a shrewd sex ratio. It is estimated that it is 5 girls to 6 boys, the so called “missing girl” phenomenon. This is very unusual, and unnatural, because in most countries the sex ratio is pretty even. Marginally more boys are born, but girls have a higher life expectancy. How come China has this abnormality then? Where did it come from? Well, the problem really started when China installed their one child policy, when families only could have one child, they would rather it would be a boy. The reason behind the male preference is tradition. It is widely believed that a son is needed to carry on the family name, to inherit and to support the parents as they grow older. These traditions caused many families to abort their daughters after their sex was identified. This has been called a gendercide, by many sources, one being Washington Times.
One of the biggest future consequences of the big difference between the number of male and female is that there will be a huge number of bachelors in China, so called “bare branches”. Since there will be more males than females, many men won’t have someone to marry and start a family with so they will be bachelors through their whole lives. Then the women might have a lot of pressure on getting many children or/and many men or it can go in the opposite direction so the women starts with prostitution and/or human trafficking.
Other consequences for the men can be that they can be more violent since they don’t have a family/wife to focus on, they might be more attracted to military-type organisations which can cause more violence, while there may be a more positive consequence for women since they might become more valued.
Written by Sol and Maria
Prenumerera på:
Inlägg (Atom)